Learn how to choose between asphalt shingles and metal roofing for your Northeast Ohio home based on durability, cost, and style. Make an informed decision for long-term protection.
When it’s time for a new roof, the choices can feel overwhelming. One of the biggest decisions is whether asphalt shingles or metal roofing is the better fit for your home. Here in Northeast Ohio, choosing the right roof isn’t just about looks—it’s about keeping your family safe from heavy snow, high winds, spring storms, and everything in between.
Roof replacement is a significant investment. The right choice will protect your home for decades, add curb appeal, and even save you money. So, how do you decide? Let’s take a clear look at the pros and cons of asphalt shingles and metal roofing specific to our Northeast Ohio climate and your unique needs.
Here in Northeast Ohio, our roofs see it all—icy winters with snow accumulation, hot days in July, fall storms, and heavy spring rains. Your roofing material must stand up to these swings.
Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material in our area for a reason. They provide solid protection in most weather, especially when professionally installed. They shed water well and offer a sturdy barrier against snow and ice. But, like anything, they have their limits. Over time, heavy snow, wind-driven rain, and sun exposure can cause them to curl, crack, or lose granules. In some cases, strong winds from summer thunderstorms or winter storms can even pull shingles loose or cause storm damage, leading to leaks that require repair.
Metal roofing is gaining popularity, especially in rural areas. It’s extremely durable and can handle all types of weather. Snow and ice generally slide right off a metal roof, reducing the risk of heavy buildup and ice dams. Metal roofs are also surprisingly good at holding up to high winds—many are rated for winds up to 120 mph. For homes in areas prone to harsh winter storms or repeated hail, metal can be a sturdy, long-lasting choice.
In summary: Both materials work in Northeast Ohio, but metal roofing can offer extra durability, especially for homes with large trees, heavy snow, or lots of wind exposure.
Cost is always a factor, but it’s important to look beyond just the price tag.
Asphalt shingles have lower upfront costs, which is why they’re on most homes in our area. The installation process is usually quicker and easier, keeping labor costs down. If you’re looking for an affordable solution to immediate storm damage repair or roof replacement, asphalt might be the most budget-friendly option. However, asphalt shingles typically last 15-25 years, sometimes a bit longer with top-tier materials and excellent care.
Metal roofing costs more upfront, due to both the materials and the specialized installation. However, metal roofs can last 40-70 years with minimal maintenance. That longevity can add up to serious savings over time—fewer repairs, no mid-life replacements, and lower insurance bills in some cases.
Also, metal roofs can increase your home’s resale value, which may offset some of their higher installation costs. If you plan to stay in your home for decades, a metal roof might actually end up saving you money in the long run.
For many homeowners, the question becomes: Do I want to spend less now and plan for another roof down the road? Or invest more today and avoid replacement for a generation or more?
Roof upkeep is a reality in Northeast Ohio. Our freeze-thaw cycles, wind-driven rains, and occasional hail can take a toll.
Asphalt shingle roofs need regular roof inspections. Look for curled, missing, or cracked shingles, especially after storms. You may see moss or algae growth, especially on shaded sides of your roof. Minor damage can often be repaired, but over time, the whole system may need replacing, particularly if leaks reach your attic or interior walls.
Metal roofing, on the other hand, is much less vulnerable to the usual forms of Northeast Ohio storm damage. It won’t crack, warp, or rot. Metal is naturally resistant to pests, mold, and moss. Still, you should check for dents after severe hail, ensure fasteners are tight, and look for signs of discoloration or corrosion (especially on older roofs). Most metal roofs are virtually maintenance-free compared with shingles—no replacing blown-off pieces after a windy night.
So, if you want a low-maintenance, long-term solution, metal is hard to beat. But asphalt shingle roofs are easy to repair. Your local roofing expert can often replace a few damaged shingles quickly after a rough winter or storm.
The look of your roof matters for your home’s overall appearance and value. You want something that fits your home’s style and matches the character of your neighborhood.
Asphalt shingles come in a wide variety of colors and textures. Some even mimic slate or wood shakes, offering lots of design flexibility at a reasonable price. In many Northeast Ohio neighborhoods, shingle roofs are the standard—your home may even have homeowner’s association guidelines or resale trends to consider.
Metal roofing used to mean only shiny silver panels, but options have grown. Metal comes in classic standing seam styles, shingles, shakes, even colors that blend with traditional homes. Its sleek, modern look can set your house apart, especially for custom builds or contemporary renovations. Still, think about whether a metal roof fits with your home’s aesthetics and your neighbors’ homes.
If you want your home to blend in, asphalt shingles may be the easier choice. If you want to stand out (and possibly raise your resale value), metal offers stunning, modern options.
Reducing heating and cooling bills is important for Northeast Ohio families. The right roof helps keep your home comfortable year-round and can lessen your impact on the environment.
Asphalt shingles offer some insulation and are available in light, reflective colors that can cut summer heat gain. However, most traditional shingles do absorb heat, which can warm your attic in hot months.
Metal roofing, especially with light colors or reflective coatings, can reflect more sunlight, keeping your home cooler in the summer. In winter, a well-insulated metal roof can help hold warmth inside. Metal roofing is often made with a significant amount of recycled material and is 100% recyclable at the end of its life. Shingles, by comparison, may end up in the landfill.
If going green or cutting long-term energy bills is a big goal for your family, metal roofing often offers the best performance.
What matters most to you? Think about your budget, how long you plan to stay in your home, energy savings, and what will look best in your neighborhood. Most importantly, make sure you have a professional roof inspection before making any big decisions—small issues, like roof deck condition or hidden leaks, could affect your options.
Usually, it’s possible to install a new metal roof over one layer of asphalt shingles. That can save on tear-off costs and speed up the installation. However, it’s important to let a professional inspect your roof first. Any hidden damage, rotten decking, or ventilation issues must be fixed first.
Metal roofs do not increase your risk of a lightning strike. In fact, if lightning does hit, a metal roof can safely disperse the energy and is non-combustible, providing excellent fire resistance.
We recommend a professional roof inspection twice a year—once each spring and fall—and after any major storm. Early detection is key, especially for storm damage repair. This simple habit can extend the life of both asphalt and metal roofs.
Most modern metal roofing systems include solid sheathing and attic insulation, which keep noise levels similar to (or even quieter than) asphalt shingles. You’ll hardly notice the difference during Northeast Ohio’s rain showers or hailstorms.
Choosing a new roof is one of the biggest decisions you'll make as a homeowner. Both asphalt shingles and metal roofing offer excellent protection when properly installed, but the right choice depends on your budget, style, and long-term plans. At M&T Roofing and Restoration, we’ve helped hundreds of Northeast Ohio families find the best solution for their homes.
Don’t leave such an important decision to guesswork. Our experienced team offers thorough roof inspections, honest advice, and detailed estimates—free of charge. Whether you’re dealing with storm damage repair, planning a full roof replacement, or weighing your options for a custom build, we’re here to help every step of the way.
Contact M&T Roofing and Restoration today to schedule your free inspection or estimate. We’ll make sure your home has the protection it deserves, no matter what Northeast Ohio’s weather brings next!
